I remember the song "Girl Next Door" by Saving Jane, an Ohio band fronted by Marti Dodson. I enjoyed the song and have the album, also named Girl Next Door, where it comes from. "Girl Next Door" is Saving Jane's biggest hit and was popular in 2005/2006.
I am unsure what Saving Jane's exact status is now: they supposedly disbanded, with some of the members, including Dodson, forming Union Rose; however, Dodson is also a part of another musical project called Sailor Sky (site plays music). I would like to see another song by Dodson become a hit, regardless of which banner she releases it under; I'm fond of her voice.