I've read in some feminist forums comments from women expressing frustration about their boyfriends or husbands refusing to buy feminine hygiene products. In those same discussions, I've also read some women say that they wouldn't date or would dump a man who wouldn't buy these items for them. I can understand these women's perspectives, but I have to ask this: just why are the men embarrassed to buy feminine hygiene products? What is their problem?
If a man is worried about being mocked for buying feminine hygiene products, he should view it this way: the mere fact he is buying these items indicates that there is an important woman in his life, who is his romantic partner, and that he is a good man for getting these things for her. He is trusted by her to get her what she needs for her body, for issues that he doesn't have to worry about in regards to his own body.
If a man is worried about being viewed as less masculine for buying them, then first, he's being immature and irrationally sensitive. Second: If people see a man buying such items, the vast majority of them will
either think nothing of it or assume that he's a caring man in a loving relationship, not a weak
excuse for a "man" who is controlled by his wife. Sure, there will be the occasional jerk who'll mock him, but so what?
That person, regardless of gender, isn't mature enough to be in a
relationship, whereas the good man is.
If a man is uncaring and disrespectful of a woman's reproductive system and women's issues, and thus regards women's hygiene as something that's beneath him, then he is a sexist and needs to grow up. Preferably sooner rather than later.
Additionally, I would argue that men who purchase pornographic magazines or similar items should feel far, far more embarrassed than men who buy their girlfriends' or wives' hygiene products. A man who buys these is likely to be viewed negatively, as people would assume he thinks that women are objects for his pleasure, rather than his fellow human beings. They also might think that he's the undateable type, hence his reliance on pornography.
I asked Dad his opinion on this topic. He shrugged, saying that he'd bought Mum her feminine products before and felt no shame in doing so. As he said, why would he? It's nothing shameful. He also thought that men who wouldn't buy them, for whatever reason, were insecure and idiots, and he agreed with me that it would be more embarrassing to be buying naughty magazines.
Oh, and one other thing: there's also the possibility that a man buying women's products could be a dad getting them for his teenage (or even adult) daughter, which would make him a great father, not a laughingstock. Honestly, there's nothing here that men need to be embarrassed about.
Haha, I remember I used to be ashamed buying those products and dad would buy them for me. I was like 12, though. But, up until 5 years ago, dad if he had to shop would buy the products for me. My last ex took me to get them if needed, but would just separate from me. Maybe it's because it's been a long time since I've been in a relationship or because of my health problems, but it's not a deal breaker for me.
ReplyDeleteYour dad is a good father. :)
DeleteI don't think I've ever asked a man to buy feminine products for me. Feminine products are like Triscuit crackers . . . there are too many choices! Haha
ReplyDeleteThat's fine; it's your body and it should be your decision, after all. :)
DeleteThat idea makes me very uncomfortable. I don't want men to pick out feminine hygiene products for me! I think that's wrong.
ReplyDeleteI don't like them buying me anything! I REFUSED to let my date buy me lunch yesterday, though I really was running low on cash, as he refuses to admit it was a date. I purchased my own Doctor Zhivago novel and meal, whatever it was again. (I was too busy talking to him about international economics to pay attention - then he chided me for eating so much I got sleepy, which I didn't appreciate. However, reflecting on it, it makes sense he'd tell me that, since he wanted to talk to me and a sleepy Claire isn't a very conversational Claire...)
On our return trip we passed by Bryn Mawr College, which got me excited again, so anyway I was happy enough to lessen the irritation over being told I ate too much (I reasoned at the time in the Chinese culture I just returned from I was told I ate too little). I should send him the map I was talking about using to navigate last tour. *does so*
Ah, reading on into your post leads me to conclude I obviously have a low level of trust with my friend. If he comments in response to my map I'll apologise for my low level of Soviet comrade trust, which is so obvious since I seriously asked around after the quality of his character and directly told him that he passed.
Or maybe I'll text him this.
I like your assertion good men buy feminine hygiene products for the women in their lives! (In Attic Greek, the good man is ός άγαθώς ἅνθροπώς. I probably even spelled it wrong since I can't be bothered to double check - it's almost right! I wasn't the most sure which kind of double accent to put over the a in anthropos).
However, I disagree with you that pornography viewers are total anathema to society, Andrew. Some of the better sexual ideas can be adapted from a good pornography flick to best fit the situation in question. (To tell you the truth, I have very high regards for the Serbian stuff!)
But most of it is indeed tasteless objectification of women, it's true. But not all of it!
As I said above to Susie, it's your body and it's your decision. If you do not want any man buying hygiene products for you, regardless of the circumstances, then that's your business and your business only (or at least it should be, anyway).
DeleteThere seems to be a lot of women who do have reason for wanting their men to buy feminine hygiene products for them and are appalled when those men don't respect that. I don't question these women (or those who feel as you do, for that matter); I just wanted to highlight the issue given that I'd read several complaints by such women and because many men don't seem to think about women's hygiene.
As for your last point, my intent wasn't to shame pornography viewers; rather, my point there was to demonstrate how ridiculous it is for a man to be embarrassed to buy something beneficial to a woman's health when society is far more likely to judge him if he buys/views pornography.
This was an awesome post! I've always felt like I would never ask a man to buy my stuff because it's my deal, my responsibility, but you're absolutely correct. There is no shame in this. Women have no shame (or shouldn't) in their body and what it does, neither should men in their lives.
ReplyDeleteThanks, I'm glad you enjoyed the post, Mandee. :) Again, it's your body and your choice, but in the event you do, for whatever reason, need or want a man to buy such items for you, you should be able to trust him to respect that and comply rather than he suddenly freak out.
DeleteOh I totally agree with this. The embarrassment stems from something so much deeper than I care to dive into in a comment, but women's reproductive systems should not be shameful to women or men. I would hope any man I date is not ashamed to buy these for me if I were in a situation where I needed him to do so. That being said, I try and get them myself just because they're my responsibility (and I'm picky about which ones I want).
ReplyDeleteExactly! You simply want to be able to depend on him if/when the circumstance arises; you should be able to trust him to do it for you and for him to not, as I said above, freak out.
DeleteNothing wrong with being picky here! :) My does assume that the woman has told her man exactly what she wants or that the man understands his wife/girlfriend well enough to know.